We have been down for nearly a week as a result of a DDoS. We needed to switch providers. We apologize for any inconvenience this may have caused.

There may be some bugs which occur as a result of the move. Please let us know if you find any.

Thank you --Robin 21:14, 15 July 2008 (UTC)

AntiVirus Comparison - Initial Cut

From CastleCopsWiki

Jump to: navigation, search
Caution The article below is currently in beta and has not been reviewed for factual errors.

On demand Scanning Freeware AntiVirus Comparison
This article compares the three freeware AntiVirus products currently available.

External Study Rankings:
All external studies referenced here, unanimously rank the on demand scanners in this order:

  1. AntiVir
  2. Avast
  3. AVG
Detection Effectiveness AntiVir Avast AVG
Mega Antivirus Test:
# Detected viruses(~10,312)
10,086 9,707 9,507
AV-comparatives 2006:1
Virus detection rate
99.51% 92.01% 91.69%
www.virus.gr Aug 2006
Virus detection rate
94.26% 87.46% 82.82%
AV-comparatives 2005:
Virus detection rate
93% 84% 83%
www.virus.gr Apr 2005
Virus detection rate
84.5% 79.7% 54%
Feature AntiVir Avast AVG
Can disinfect archives/nested
archives on demand

Yes2 Yes No3
Can scan on demand in quiet mode
(requires no user intervention)

Yes No No
Guard can be set to scan in quiet mode
(requires no user intervention)

Yes No No
Guard can scan real-time/
archives/nested archives
:
No Yes No
Autoupdating:
Yes4 Yes Yes
Autoscheduling:
Yes No Yes
Resource usage:5
Email scanning:
Yes Yes Yes
Scans in Safe Mode Yes Yes Yes
Boot Scan Option No Yes TBA
GUI and user friendliness
Supported OSs Win98
Win NT
Win2K
Win XP
Win 95
Win 98
Win Me
Win NT45
Win 2K5
Win XP6
Vista
Win 95
Win 98
Win Me
Win NT45
Win 2K5
Win XP6

Notes
1 Compares Pro Versions which have identical or nearly identical detection as freeware versions
2 Offers boot scan disinfect; New Beta Version 7 offers immediate disinfect
3 Can detect but cannot disinfect
4 If configured with /AH option in scheduler; New Beta Version 4 has autoupdating feature
5 No major difference in Performance
6 Windows Server OSs are not supported in the freeware version

Contents

[edit] Products Compared

[edit] AntiVir

http://www.free-av.com/

PersonalEdition Classic

Parallel to the new AntiVir PersonalEdition Premium there is still as a matter of course the popular and known cost-free AntiVir PersonalEdition freeware. Only the name and the colour are new: The cost-free virus protection is called as AntiVir PersonalEdition Classic now.


Coming Soon ....The Avira Rootkit Beta

[edit] Avast Personal Edition v 4.5

http://www.avast.com/eng/avast_4_home.html

avast! 4 Home Edition is a full-featured antivirus package designed exclusively for home users and non-commercial use. Both of these conditions should be met! Our company offers the Home Edition free of charge, since, in our opinion, it is possible to avoid global virus spreading by efficient prevention; however, many user are not able to or do not want to pay for antivirus software. This page will show you the most important features of this program.

Institutions (even non-commercial ones) are not allowed to use avast! Home Edition. However, ALWIL Software provides the full line of avast! antivirus products at special discount prices for non-profit, charity, educational and government institutions. Please see our price lists for details.

Major Features at a Glance:

  • Automatic updating
  • ADS Scanning
  • Simplified User Interface
  • Virus Chest (Quarantine Folder)
  • Resident protection
  • System integration (Boot-time scan support)
  • P2P and IM Shields
  • Integrated Virus Cleaner
  • Network Shield (Intrusion Detection System (IDS) component that protects against WORM attacks)
  • 64-bit Windows Support
  • Web Shield (Filters http traffic for malware threats)
  • Multi-Language User Interface

[edit] AVG

http://www.grisoft.com/doc/289/lng/us/tpl/tpl01

Availability

AVG Free Edition is available free-of-charge to home users! AVG Free Edition is for private, non-commercial, single home computer use only. Use of AVG Free Edition within any organization or for commercial purposes is strictly prohibited.

[edit] Features Compared

[edit] On-demand archive disinfection

Disinfection of archives and nested archives on demand is an important feature. Archives include zip files. Nesting refers to archives which are contained within archives (e.g. a zip file within a zip file). "On demand" refers to the real-time ability of disinfecting archives when received.

Archives can be in various formats and can be nested to various depths and these aspects are explored in the more detailed Technical Comparison.

[edit] On-demand scanning

[edit] Archive scanning

[edit] Autoupdating

[edit] Autoscheduling

[edit] Resource usage

This performance consideration compared how much computer resources are used.

All three products use minimal resources and no major difference in performance was observed.

[edit] Email scanning

[edit] Scans in Safe Mode

[edit] GUI Design

[edit] Supported OSs

[edit] Technical Comparison

Criteria AntiVir Avast AVG
Effectiveness of Realtime scanners
  1. Scan archives (zip,rar etc)
  2. Scan packers (UPX)
  3. On execution
  4. On read/write/creation
  5. Scan using heuristics
  6. Block script files
  7. Customised directories not to scan
  8. Customised file sizes not to scan
  9. Customised extensions to scan
  10. Scan of floppy,cd,network drives
  • AntiVir 1st
  • 2nd
  • 3rd
  • 4th
  • 5th
  • 6th
  • 7th
  • 8th
  • 9th
  • 10th
Avast 1st
2nd
3rd
4th
5th
6th
7th
8th
9th
10th

AVG 1st
2nd
3rd
4th
5th
6th
7th
8th
9th
10th

Effectiveness of email scanner
  1. transparent proxy scanner?
  2. scan incoming and outgoing mail
  3. Scan archives (zip,rar etc)
  4. Scan packers (UPX)
  5. On execution
  6. On read/write/creation
  7. Scan using heuristics
  8. Block script files
  9. Customised directories not to scan
  10. Customised file sizes not to scan
  11. Customised extensions to scan
  12. Scan of floppy,cd,network drives
Effectiveness of scanners in general
  1. Types of archives scanned including specific mail archives mbx etc
  2. Types of packers scanned
  3. Number of nested levels it scans for archives
  4. Memory scanner (not process module memory scanner)
  5. Scans spyware/cookies etc
  6. Scans NTFS from a rescue disk?
Updater citeria
  1. Allows use of proxy
  2. Allows incremental signature updates
Misc
  1. Adds scan to explorer context menu
  2. Allows scan on boot scan
  3. Allows scan on networked drives,CD,floppies
  4. Specialised scanner for IM , P2P or HTTP scanner
  5. Skinnable
  6. Alerts via email,messenger service
Personal tools